Why You Shouldn't Just Sign Your Bank's Renewal Offer

It arrives in your mailbox with a sense of routine. It’s a simple, one-page letter from your bank, the institution you’ve been with for years. It's your mortgage renewal offer. The process looks incredibly easy: a "special" rate is offered, and all you have to do is sign on the dotted line and send it back. It’s a tempting, hassle-free path.

But that convenience is a carefully designed illusion. By simply signing that letter, homeowners across Ontario could be leaving thousands, or even tens of thousands, of dollars on the table. You are likely falling victim to a well-known secret in the Canadian banking industry: the "loyalty penalty."

This guide will expose the hidden costs of blindly auto-renewing your mortgage with your bank. We will explain why your loyalty is often punished, not rewarded, and provide a clear, step-by-step plan on how to use a mortgage broker to introduce competition and ensure you get the absolute best deal the market has to offer.

The Bank's Strategy: Convenience Over Competition

To understand why the offer in your mailbox is likely not the best one, you need to understand the bank's business model.

The Psychology of the Renewal Letter

The renewal offer you receive is a masterpiece of marketing and behavioural psychology. It is designed to be as frictionless as possible.

It arrives close to your renewal date, creating a sense of urgency.

It looks simple and official, implying this is just a standard administrative step.

The offered rate often seems "reasonable." It might be slightly better than their highly inflated "posted" rates, creating a false sense of getting a good deal.

The entire process is designed to make you think that signing the form is the easiest and most logical thing to do.

The "Loyalty Penalty" Explained

Here is the core concept that your bank does not want you to know. They are betting that the vast majority of their existing clients—studies have shown over 60%—will simply sign the first renewal offer they receive out of convenience. They know you are busy, and that shopping for a mortgage seems like a complicated and time-consuming hassle.

Because they believe you won't leave, they have zero incentive to offer you their best, most competitive interest rate. The rate on your renewal letter is almost always higher than the rate they are offering to a brand new client they are trying to win over from a competitor. This difference between the rate they offer you (their loyal client) and the best rate they would offer a new client is the loyalty penalty. It’s the price you pay for your convenience.

Learn more about home equity loans in Ontario

Check your eligibility in under 60 secs.

See How Much I Qualify For

The Broker's Strategy: Forcing the Competition

As independent mortgage brokers, our entire business model is built on disrupting this loyalty penalty. Our process is designed to introduce powerful competition into the renewal process to save you money.

We Work For You, Not the Bank

This is the fundamental difference. A bank's mortgage specialist works for the bank. Their job is to maximize the bank's profit on your renewal. As licensed mortgage brokers in Ontario, our legal and ethical duty is to you, the client. Our only goal is to find you the best possible mortgage deal, which almost always means finding the lowest interest rate.

The Power of Shopping the Market

When your renewal comes up, we don't just ask your bank for a better rate; we force them to compete for your business. The process is simple and powerful:

You provide us with a copy of your renewal offer and a standard application.

We take your application to the entire mortgage market. This includes dozens of lenders: major banks (yes, even your own!), national monoline lenders who only work with brokers, and local credit unions.

This creates a bidding war for your business. We come back to you with the best, fully-approved offer from the open market. We can then either proceed with that new lender or take that superior offer back to your current bank and give them one final chance to match or beat it. This strategy puts you in the driver's seat.

The "Switch" or "Transfer" Process

Many homeowners are hesitant to move their mortgage because they fear a complex and costly process. However, for a straightforward renewal where you aren't borrowing more money (a "switch" or "transfer"), the process is remarkably simple. Most new lenders will cover the legal and administrative costs of the switch to earn your business. This means that moving your mortgage to a lender with a better rate is often completely free for you.

A Real-World Renewal Case Study

Let's look at the real-world financial impact of this choice with a common scenario.

The Client and The Bank's Offer

The "Jacksons" are a family with a $600,000 mortgage coming up for renewal. They have been with their major bank for over 15 years. Their bank sends them a renewal letter offering a new 5-year fixed term at 5.19%. It seems okay in the current market, and they are tempted to just sign it to get it done.

The Broker's Analysis

Instead, they contact our brokerage. We take their application to our network of over 50 lenders. After a day of shopping the market, we find that the best available 5-year fixed rate for a client with their profile from a competitive monoline lender is 4.89%.

The Shocking Difference in Cost

This is where the power of competition becomes clear. Let's look at the math:

The Bank's Offer (5.19%):

Monthly Payment: ~$3,555

Total Interest Paid over 5 Years: ~$148,150

The Broker's Offer (4.89%):

Monthly Payment: ~$3,445

Total Interest Paid over 5 Years: ~$139,100

The Result: By taking 30 minutes to contact a mortgage broker instead of simply signing the letter, the Jacksons will save $9,050 in interest over their next 5-year term. That's $9,050 of their hard-earned money that stays in their pocket. It's enough for a fantastic family vacation, a full year of RESP contributions for a child, or a significant boost to their retirement savings—all from one phone call.

Your Mortgage Renewal Action Plan

Being proactive is the key to saving money. Don't wait for the renewal letter to arrive.

The 120-Day Window

Most lenders will allow you to renew your mortgage and lock in a new rate up to 120 days (four months) before your official maturity date. You should mark this date in your calendar. Starting the process early protects you from any potential rate hikes and gives you plenty of time to shop the market without pressure.

The Simple Steps

When you receive your renewal letter from your bank, read it, but do not sign it.

Contact our brokerage immediately.

We handle the rest. We'll compare your bank's offer to the entire market and come back to you with a clear analysis of your best options.

Shop Around for a Better Deal

Your mortgage renewal is not just an administrative task; it is your single best opportunity to save thousands of dollars without changing your lifestyle. Your bank's renewal offer is not a reward for your loyalty; it is a starting point for a negotiation. And the only way to ensure you get a fair and truly competitive rate is to introduce powerful competition into the process.

Don't pay the loyalty penalty. Contact our brokerage today, and let us shop the market to ensure you're not leaving any of your money on the table.

Get Personalized Advice

with an Award-Winning Mortgage Broker

4.9 from 812 reviews

Schedule My Call