Why Are Second Mortgage Rates Higher? A Broker Explains

It’s one of the most common moments of "sticker shock" a homeowner can experience. You have a primary mortgage with a great interest rate—say, 4.0%—that you’re comfortable with. You decide to tap into your home's equity to fund a renovation or consolidate some debt and inquire about a second mortgage. When the quote comes back, the rate is 9.0%, 10%, or even higher.

The immediate reaction is understandable: "Why is the rate so much higher than my first mortgage? Is this a rip-off?"

It’s a fair question, and the answer is no, it's not a rip-off. But the rate is higher for a very specific and logical reason. This guide will provide a clear and transparent explanation of exactly why second mortgage rates are higher. It's not arbitrary; it's based on a fundamental lending principle that is crucial for every homeowner to understand: risk. We will break down the concept of "lien position" and show you how to calculate your true "blended rate" to see the real cost.

The Most Important Factor: Lien Position

The number one reason second mortgages have higher interest rates is due to a legal concept known as lien position.

What is a "Lien" on Your Property?

In simple terms, a lien is a legal claim against an asset—in this case, your property—for a debt that is owed. When you get a mortgage, the lender registers a lien (also called a "charge") on the title of your home. This gives them the legal right to sell your property to recoup their money if you fail to make your payments.

First Position vs. Second Position

When you have more than one mortgage on your property, each loan is registered on the title in a specific order. The first one registered is in "first position." The next one is in "second position," and so on.

Think of it like a lineup at a cash register. The lender of your first mortgage is first in line to get paid. The lender of your second mortgage is second in line. This order is critically important.

The Risk of Being Second in Line

Being second in line is always riskier than being first. In a normal scenario where you make all your payments, this order doesn't really matter. But if you default on your loans and the property has to be sold under a Power of Sale, the lender in first position gets paid back in full before the lender in second position sees a single dollar.

A Real-World Default Example

Let's use clear numbers to illustrate the significant risk a second mortgage lender takes.

A home has a fair market value of $1,000,000.

It has a first mortgage with a balance of $750,000.

It also has a second mortgage with a balance of $100,000.

The homeowner defaults on their payments. In a down market, the primary lender sells the property under Power of Sale for only $800,000.

Here’s how the money is distributed:

First, the real estate commissions and legal fees for the sale are paid (e.g., ~$40,000). This leaves $760,000.

Next, the first mortgage lender (who is first in line) gets their entire $750,000 back.

This leaves only $10,000 for the second mortgage lender. They are owed $100,000, but they only receive $10,000, resulting in a $90,000 loss.

This example clearly demonstrates why lending in second position is inherently riskier. The higher interest rate on a second mortgage is direct compensation for the lender taking on this significantly higher risk of loss.

Learn more about home equity loans in Ontario

Check your eligibility in under 60 secs.

See How Much I Qualify For

Other Factors That Influence the Rate

Lien position is the biggest factor, but other elements also contribute to the final interest rate you're offered.

The Borrower's Credit Profile

Often, homeowners seek a second mortgage because they don't qualify to refinance their first mortgage with a prime 'A' lender. This could be due to a "bruised" credit score (typically below 680) or a recent life event that has impacted their finances. Many second mortgages are provided by B-Lenders or Private Lenders who specialize in these situations. Part of the higher interest rate reflects the increased risk associated with a borrower's credit profile that falls outside the big banks' strictest guidelines.

Loan-to-Value (LTV)

The total LTV on your property also impacts the rate. A second mortgage that brings your total borrowing to 75% of your home's value is less risky than one that pushes the total borrowing to the maximum of 85% or 90% (if available). The higher the LTV, the less equity "cushion" there is to protect the lenders in a market downturn, so the rate for a high-LTV loan will be higher.

Loan Size and Term Length

Administrative and legal costs for a $50,000 mortgage are very similar to those for a $200,000 mortgage. To compensate for this, lenders often charge slightly higher interest rates on smaller loan amounts. Furthermore, the very short terms of most second mortgages (typically 1 to 3 years) mean the lender has a much shorter window to earn a return on their investment, which can also be factored into the rate.

How to Calculate Your "Blended" Rate

Looking at the high interest rate of a second mortgage in isolation can be misleading. To understand the true cost of borrowing, a broker will help you calculate your "blended" or "effective" rate across your total home debt.

How to See the Bigger Picture

This calculation shows you the weighted average interest rate you are paying on all the money secured by your home. It provides a much more strategic and less intimidating perspective on the cost.

A Step-by-Step Blended Rate Calculation

Let's look at a common scenario. You have a great low rate on your first mortgage and you want to borrow an additional $50,000.

First Mortgage: $500,000 balance at a low 3.0% interest rate.

New Second Mortgage: $50,000 at a 9.0% interest rate.

Your Total Debt: You now have a total of $550,000 secured against your home.

Now, let's calculate the total annual interest cost:

Annual Interest on 1st Mortgage: $500,000 x 0.03 = $15,000

Annual Interest on 2nd Mortgage: $50,000 x 0.09 = $4,500

Total Annual Interest Cost: $15,000 + $4,500 = $19,500

Finally, we calculate the blended rate:

(Total Annual Interest Cost ÷ Total Debt) x 100 = Blended Rate

($19,500 ÷ $550,000) x 100 = 3.55%

The Real Comparison

As you can see, while you borrowed the new funds at 9.0%, the effective interest rate on your total home debt only increased from 3.0% to 3.55%. This is the true cost of accessing that extra $50,000, and it's a much more manageable number than the standalone 9.0% rate.

A Fair Price for a Valuable Tool

Second mortgage rates are not arbitrarily high; they are a logical and fair price that compensates the lender for taking on a significantly higher risk than your primary bank. When viewed through the strategic lens of a blended rate, a second mortgage is often a very cost-effective tool.

Whether it’s to avoid a massive penalty on your first mortgage, to fund a renovation that will add significant value to your home, or to seize a business opportunity, a second mortgage can be a powerful and intelligent financial move.

If you're considering accessing your home's equity, the first step is to understand all your options and their true costs. Contact our brokerage today for a full analysis of a second mortgage and to see what your personalized "blended rate" would be.

Get Personalized Advice

with an Award-Winning Mortgage Broker

4.9 from 812 reviews

Schedule My Call