The Pros and Cons of an Open vs. Closed Mortgage

When you’re shopping for a mortgage in Canada, the interest rate often gets all the attention. While it’s certainly important, there’s a more fundamental choice you need to make first that will have a far greater impact on your financial flexibility: should you get an open or a closed mortgage? This decision is the bedrock of your mortgage strategy, as it defines the rules of engagement between you and your lender for years to come.

The choice between an open vs. closed mortgage boils down to a classic trade-off: cost versus flexibility. This guide will provide a clear, detailed comparison of these two core mortgage structures. We’ll break down how they differ on interest rates, prepayment flexibility, and the significant costs associated with mortgage penalties. Understanding this difference is the key to choosing a mortgage that fits not just your budget, but your life.

The Default Choice: A Closed Mortgage

The vast majority of mortgages held by Canadian homeowners are closed mortgages. When you see a lender advertising a competitive 5-year fixed or variable rate, they are advertising a closed mortgage product.

What is a Closed Mortgage?

A closed mortgage is a contract between you and a lender for a specific period of time (the term), at a specific interest rate. A typical term is five years. In exchange for giving you a highly competitive interest rate, you are committing to keeping your mortgage with that lender and paying it down under the agreed-upon terms for that full period.

Think of it as a bulk-purchase discount. You're promising the lender your business for a set number of years, and in return, they give you their best pricing. If you want to break that promise—by paying the mortgage off early, selling your home, or refinancing elsewhere—you will almost certainly face a significant prepayment penalty.

The Pros of a Closed Mortgage

Much Lower Interest Rates: This is the number one reason closed mortgages are so popular. The interest rates on closed mortgages are significantly lower than on open mortgages. Over the life of a loan, this difference can save you tens of thousands of dollars in interest costs.

Rate Stability and Budgeting: With a fixed-rate closed mortgage, your interest rate and principal-and-interest payment are locked in for the entire term. This provides stability and makes it incredibly easy to budget your monthly expenses, as your single biggest cost will not change.

Wide Variety of Options: Because they are the most common type of mortgage, there is a huge and competitive market for closed mortgage products, with options for different terms (from 1 to 10 years), rates (fixed and variable), and features.

The Cons of a Closed Mortgage

Significant Prepayment Penalties: This is the major drawback. If your life circumstances change and you need to break your mortgage contract before the end of your term, the penalty can be substantial. As we’ve detailed in other guides, the cost of breaking a closed mortgage can be tens of thousands of dollars, especially if you have a fixed-rate mortgage and interest rates have fallen.

Limited Prepayment Flexibility: While most closed mortgages are not completely locked-in, your ability to pay it down faster is limited. Most lenders allow you to make lump-sum prepayments (usually 10-20% of the original principal per year) and increase your monthly payments by a certain percentage. However, if you come into a large sum of money (like an inheritance) that exceeds these limits, you cannot pay off the mortgage in full without triggering the penalty.

Who is a Closed Mortgage Best For?

A closed mortgage is the ideal choice for the majority of homeowners, particularly those who:

Are financially stable and have a predictable income.

Do not plan on selling their home or moving in the near future.

Want to secure the lowest possible interest rate to minimize their borrowing costs.

Learn more about home equity loans in Ontario

Check your eligibility in under 60 secs.

See How Much I Qualify For

The Flexible Alternative: An Open Mortgage

An open mortgage is the polar opposite of a closed mortgage when it comes to flexibility. It is designed for homeowners who need short-term financing or who anticipate being able to pay off their mortgage much sooner than the term dictates.

What is an Open Mortgage?

An open mortgage offers you the ultimate freedom to pay back your loan whenever you want. You can make extra payments of any amount, at any time, or pay off the entire mortgage in full, all without facing any prepayment penalties. It’s a completely flexible borrowing tool.

Think of it as a pay-as-you-go service. You get maximum flexibility, but you pay a premium for it in the form of a much higher interest rate.

The Pros of an Open Mortgage

Complete Prepayment Freedom: This is its sole, powerful advantage. You can pay off the mortgage tomorrow with no penalty. This is perfect for people who are expecting a large influx of cash.

Peace of Mind in Uncertainty: If you’re in a situation where your future is uncertain—perhaps you’re planning a move but don’t know when, or you’re in a short-term financial situation—an open mortgage allows you to exit the loan without penalty whenever your plans become clear.

The Cons of an Open Mortgage

Significantly Higher Interest Rates: The price for this flexibility is steep. Open mortgage rates are always much higher than closed mortgage rates, often by 2% or more. This makes them an extremely expensive way to finance a home over the long term.

Usually Variable Rates: The vast majority of open mortgages come with a variable interest rate, meaning the rate (and your payment) will fluctuate with the lender’s prime rate. This adds a layer of unpredictability to your budget.

Limited Product Options: There are far fewer lenders and products available in the open mortgage market.

Who is an Open Mortgage Best For?

An open mortgage is a niche product designed for very specific, short-term scenarios. It is a good fit for homeowners who:

Are planning to sell their home within the next few months and need financing in the interim.

Are expecting a large, imminent cash windfall (e.g., from an inheritance, the sale of another property, or a business settlement) and want to pay off the mortgage as soon as the funds arrive.

Require maximum flexibility due to a volatile or uncertain personal or financial situation.

Head-to-Head Comparison: Open vs. Closed

To make the choice clearer, let’s compare the two structures side-by-side on the factors that matter most.

Interest Rates

This is the most straightforward comparison. Closed mortgages win, hands down. The rate on a 5-year fixed closed mortgage will be dramatically lower than the rate on an open mortgage. Choosing an open mortgage is a deliberate decision to pay a significant premium for flexibility.

Flexibility & Penalties

Here, the roles are reversed. Open mortgages are the clear winner. Their defining feature is the freedom to pay off the loan at any time without penalty. A closed mortgage, by contrast, is defined by its restrictions. While features like portability (the ability to "move" your mortgage to a new property) can add some flexibility to a closed mortgage, it doesn't compare to the complete freedom of an open one.

Scenarios & Use Cases

Scenario 1: The Stable Homeowner. A family buys their long-term home, they have stable jobs, and they plan to stay for at least the next five years. The Verdict: A closed mortgage is the only logical choice. They will save an enormous amount of money with a lower interest rate, and they don't need the expensive flexibility of an open mortgage.

Scenario 2: The House Flipper. An investor buys a property, plans to do a quick three-month renovation, and then sell it for a profit. The Verdict: An open mortgage is the perfect tool for property flippers. The higher interest rate for a few months is a small business expense compared to the massive penalty they would face for breaking a closed mortgage after such a short time.

Scenario 3: The Inheritor. Someone is buying a home today but knows they will be receiving a large inheritance in about a year that will be enough to pay off the entire mortgage. The Verdict: An open mortgage makes sense here. They can pay the higher rate for one year and then use the inheritance to clear the debt, penalty-free.

Aligning Your Mortgage with Your Life

The open vs. closed mortgage debate isn't about which product is universally "better"—it's about which product is better for you, right now. A closed mortgage offers significant savings and is the right choice for the vast majority of Canadians in stable situations. An open mortgage offers unparalleled flexibility, serving as a valuable short-term tool for those in specific, transitional circumstances.

Choosing the wrong one can be a costly mistake. Opting for an open mortgage when you don't need it can mean paying thousands in unnecessary interest. Conversely, getting locked into a closed mortgage when you know a move is on the horizon can lead to crippling penalties. This is why a thorough conversation about your plans and goals is so critical. The next time you're thinking about refinancing your mortgage, our team at 360Lending can help you look beyond the advertised rates to structure a mortgage that provides the stability you need and the flexibility you might require in the years to come.

Get Personalized Advice

with an Award-Winning Mortgage Broker

4.9 from 812 reviews

Schedule My Call