Life happens. You land a dream job offer in another city, your family grows and you need to upsize, you go through a separation, or interest rates drop so dramatically that you could save a fortune by refinancing. These are all common life events, but if you have a mortgage, they often come with a massive and confusing obstacle: the prepayment penalty.

Often called a "breakage fee," this penalty can amount to tens of thousands of dollars, making homeowners feel trapped in a mortgage that no longer fits their life. But what if you understood exactly how this penalty was calculated? What if you knew the insider strategies to minimize or even avoid it altogether?

This guide will demystify mortgage penalties. We will explain why they exist and provide a clear, step-by-step guide to calculating them. Most importantly, we'll share a broker's strategies that can help you make your next move without breaking the bank.

Why Do Lenders Charge Prepayment Penalties?

It can feel unfair to be charged a huge fee for paying back the money you borrowed. But to understand the penalty, it helps to look at it from the lender's perspective.

A Look from the Lender's Perspective

When a lender gives you a 5-year fixed mortgage at 3.0%, they have often secured the funds for that loan for a 5-year term at a specific cost to them. Their profit is the "spread" between their cost and the rate they charge you, calculated over the full 5 years. If you break that contract early—for example, three years in—they lose out on two years of expected profit. The prepayment penalty is how they recoup that potential loss. It's a clause in your mortgage contract that protects the lender's business model.

Difference Between Open & Closed Mortgages

It's important to note that these penalties almost always apply to closed mortgages. A closed mortgage offers a lower interest rate in exchange for your commitment to stay for the full term. An open mortgage can be paid off at any time without penalty, but the interest rates are significantly higher. The vast majority of mortgages in Canada are closed, which is why understanding prepayment penalties is so crucial.

Learn more about home equity loans in Ontario

Check your eligibility in under 60 secs.

See How Much I Qualify For

The 2 Types of Penalty Calculations

When you break a closed mortgage, your lender will calculate your penalty in two ways and, as per your contract, you are required to pay whichever amount is greater.

Method 1: Three Months' Interest

This is the simpler and almost always cheaper penalty calculation. It's the standard penalty for breaking a variable-rate mortgage and is sometimes used for fixed-rate mortgages in specific, favourable situations. The formula is straightforward and transparent.

The Formula: (Current Mortgage Balance x Your Annual Interest Rate) ÷ 12 x 3 = Penalty

A Clear Example: Let's say you have a mortgage balance of $500,000 at an interest rate of 5.0%.

($500,000 x 0.05) ÷ 12 x 3 = $6,250

Your penalty would be a straightforward $6,250.

Method 2: The Interest Rate Differential (IRD)

This is the more complex and often shockingly expensive penalty. The IRD is the standard penalty for breaking a fixed-rate mortgage. The concept is that the lender calculates how much interest they will lose by you breaking the contract, and they charge you that difference.

Breaking down the complex calculation into simple steps:

Find Your Rate: This is the interest rate on your current mortgage contract. Let's say it's 5.5%.

Find the Lender's Current Rate: The lender looks at their current interest rate for a new mortgage with a term that is closest to the time you have remaining on your mortgage. If you have 2 years left on your 5-year term, they will look at their current 2-year fixed rate. Let's say it's 3.5%.

Calculate the Rate Difference: The difference between your rate and their current rate is 2.0% (5.5% - 3.5%).

Calculate the Final Penalty: The formula is roughly: (Mortgage Balance x Rate Difference x Months Remaining) ÷ 12 = IRD Penalty

($500,000 x 0.02 x 24 months) ÷ 12 = $20,000

Your IRD penalty would be a massive $20,000, which is much greater than the Three Months' Interest penalty.

A Broker's Secret: Posted vs. Discounted Rates

Here is a crucial piece of insider information that can save you thousands. When the big banks calculate your IRD penalty, they often compare your contract rate to their much higher, publicly advertised "posted" rates, not the lower, discounted rates they actually give to new clients. This inflates the rate difference and results in a much larger penalty for you.

In contrast, monoline lenders (who only work through mortgage brokers) typically use their actual discounted rates in the calculation. This often results in a significantly fairer and smaller penalty. This difference in calculation methods is one of the most important, yet least-known, advantages of securing your mortgage through a broker.

A Broker's Guide to Minimizing Penalties

You are not powerless against penalties. A proactive strategy, guided by expert advice, can save you a significant amount of money.

Strategy 1: Keep Your Mortgage, Add a Second

Why break a fantastic low-rate mortgage if you don't have to? If you need to access cash—for a renovation, debt consolidation, or an investment—but are facing a massive prepayment penalty, the best move is often to leave your great first mortgage untouched.

Instead, we can arrange a second mortgage or a Home Equity Line of Credit (HELOC) that sits behind your primary one. While the interest rate on this second loan will be higher, it only applies to the smaller amount you're borrowing.

For example, imagine you have a $500,000 mortgage at a low 2.5% rate, but you need $50,000 in cash. Breaking it would cost you a $12,000 penalty. Instead, we can arrange a $50,000 second mortgage at a higher rate, say 8.0%. Your overall "blended" interest rate across all your debt is still very low, and you've completely avoided the $12,000 penalty. This is an ideal solution when the penalty is large and the need for new funds is relatively small.

Strategy 2: Blend and Extend with Your Lender

If you want a lower rate but wish to stay with your current lender, you can ask to "blend and extend." This involves blending your old, lower rate with their current, higher rate and signing up for a new, longer term (like a new 5-year term). You avoid a penalty this way, but you may not be getting the absolute best interest rate available on the open market.

Strategy 3: Port Your Mortgage to a New Home

If you are moving, you can often "port" or transfer your existing mortgage—and its great interest rate—from the property you're selling to the new one you're buying. This is a fantastic way to avoid a penalty entirely. If you need to borrow more money for the new, more expensive home, we can often arrange a blended rate or add a second mortgage component.

Strategy 4: Use Your Prepayment Privileges

This is a key money-saving tactic that requires planning. Most closed mortgages allow you to pay down a lump sum (e.g., 15-20%) each year without penalty. If you know you will be breaking your mortgage, you can make the maximum allowable prepayment just before you do. This reduces the principal balance on which the final, larger penalty is calculated, which can save you a substantial amount.

Is Breaking Your Mortgage Ever Worth It?

Sometimes, paying the penalty is the smartest financial move you can make. This is a pure cost-benefit analysis that we, as brokers, perform for our clients every day.

Consider this scenario:

Your calculated IRD penalty to break your mortgage today is $8,000.

However, current interest rates have dropped so significantly that by refinancing, you would save $15,000 in interest payments over the next three years.

In this case, paying the $8,000 fee is an easy decision. It's a short-term cost that unlocks a long-term net savings of $7,000. We can lay out these numbers for you in black and white.

Calculate Your Mortgage Penalty

Mortgage penalties are complex, intimidating, and often feel unfair. But they are not a life sentence; they are just math. A homeowner should never feel trapped in a mortgage that no longer serves their life's goals. By understanding how the calculations work and exploring all the strategic options available, you can make a clear, informed decision that protects your finances.

The first step is to know your numbers. Contact our brokerage today for a free, no-obligation penalty calculation and a full review of your options. We'll help you find the most cost-effective path forward.

Get Personalized Advice

with an Award-Winning Mortgage Broker

4.9

from 812 reviews

Schedule My Call