Different Types of Mortgage Lenders in Canada Explained

When you're looking for a mortgage in Canada, it's easy to think that the "best" lender is simply the one with the lowest advertised interest rate. But the truth is, the "best" mortgage lender doesn't exist. The best lender is the one that is right for your specific financial situation and goals right now.

Most Canadians only ever interact with one type of lender—their primary bank, also known as a Prime ('A') lender. When that bank says "no" to a mortgage application, many borrowers believe their journey is over. They are completely unaware that two other complete tiers of lending—Subprime ('B') Lenders and Private Lenders—exist, each designed to serve different, specific needs.

Using the wrong type of lender for your situation can lead to a frustrating denial or a costly, ill-fitting mortgage. This guide will act as your strategic roadmap. Instead of just defining the lenders, we will walk you through different real-world scenarios to help you understand which tier of lending is the perfect fit for your unique needs.

Scenario 1: The "Straightforward" File

This is the classic, ideal mortgage application that fits perfectly within the traditional banking system.

The Borrower Profile

Let's call this borrower "The Planner." The Planner is a salaried T4 employee with a stable job history of three years at the same company. They have a strong credit score of 740, have diligently saved a 20% down payment for their home, and have a low amount of other debt (perhaps a small, manageable car payment).

The Financial Goal

The Planner's goal is simple and clear: to purchase a primary residence for their family and to secure the absolute lowest interest rate possible over a 5-year fixed term. They are a low-risk borrower, and their priority is cost savings.

The Right Tool for the Job

For this "perfect" file, the Prime ('A') Lender market is the correct and only place to be. This includes the major banks, credit unions, and monoline lenders. Their strict guidelines are designed for exactly this type of client, and they reward this low-risk profile with their most competitive, rock-bottom interest rates.

A Broker's Strategy (Even When It's "Easy")

Even for a perfect applicant like The Planner, the strategy isn't to simply walk into their personal bank and accept the first offer. This is a common mistake that can leave thousands of dollars on the table. A bank knows that their existing clients are unlikely to shop around, so they often don't offer their very best rate upfront.

As mortgage brokers, our role here is to create a bidding war for this excellent client. We take their single application and present it to dozens of Prime lenders across the country, including broker-only monoline lenders who often have even better rates than the big banks. By forcing the lenders to compete, we can secure an interest rate that is often significantly lower than what the client's own bank would have offered them, saving them a substantial amount of money over their mortgage term.

Learn more about home equity loans in Ontario

Check your eligibility in under 60 secs.

See How Much I Qualify For

Scenario 2: The "Real-World" File

This scenario represents a huge number of hardworking Canadians whose financial picture doesn't fit the banks' narrow definition of "perfect."

The Borrower Profile

Let's call this borrower "The Entrepreneur." The Entrepreneur could be a self-employed contractor with a very successful business, but who works with a smart accountant to write off legitimate expenses, resulting in a low "on-paper" net income on their tax returns.

Alternatively, this borrower could be a couple with two strong, stable incomes, but a "bruised" credit score in the low 600s due to a past event, like a divorce or a period of illness, that they have since recovered from.

The Financial Goal

The Entrepreneur's goal is often to refinance their mortgage to consolidate debt or to get approved for a home purchase after their own bank has said "no" due to their non-traditional income or their credit score.

The Right Tool for the Job

This is the exact scenario where a Subprime ('B') Lender is the perfect fit. These regulated financial institutions specialize in "common-sense" underwriting. They know how to look at business bank statements to see the true cash flow of a self-employed individual. They are also willing to look past a lower credit score if the borrower has a good down payment and a clear story explaining their past credit issues.

The Broker's Strategy

A Subprime mortgage is not a "bad" loan; it's a strategic tool. As brokers, we position a B-lender mortgage as a temporary, 1- to 3-year solution designed to solve an immediate problem. The goal is to get the client the financing they need today. We then work with them during that term to improve their financial file—whether that's by establishing a new track record of perfect payments to boost their credit score, or by filing a couple of years of stronger tax returns. At the end of the term, our goal is always to have improved their situation enough to move them up to a Prime lender with the best rates at renewal.

Scenario 3: The "Complex" File

This scenario is for borrowers with the most time-sensitive or complex situations, where the property itself is the strongest part of the application.

The Borrower Profile

Let's look at two common personas here. The first is a Real Estate Investor who has found a distressed property that needs significant renovations—a classic "property flip." The second is a Homeowner with a huge amount of equity in their home who has fallen behind on payments and is facing an urgent Power of Sale.

The Financial Goal

For both of these borrowers, the primary need is speed and flexibility. The investor needs to close on the deal in 10 days before another buyer can. The homeowner needs to access funds immediately to pay their arrears and stop a legal action.

The Right Tool for the Job

For these asset-rich, complex, and urgent situations, a Private Lender is the right strategic tool. A private mortgage is "equity-based." The lender is less concerned with the borrower's personal income or credit score; their decision is based almost entirely on the value of the property. If there is a lot of equity, a private lender can provide funds in a matter of days.

The Broker's Strategy

As brokers, we position a private loan as a very short-term "bridge" to get a client from a crisis to a solution. The single most important part of our strategy is designing a clear and realistic "exit strategy" from day one. For the investor, the exit is selling the renovated property or refinancing to a B-lender. For the homeowner, the exit is using the time to fix their financial situation so they can refinance back to a traditional lender. We never arrange a private mortgage without this clear path out.

Choosing the Right Type of Mortgage Lender

Your financial situation isn't a permanent label; it's a scenario. And every scenario has a specific lending solution that is best suited to it. A "no" from a Prime lender is not a dead end; it's simply an indicator that you need a different tool for the job.

A mortgage broker's true value is not just in finding low rates, but in our ability to accurately diagnose a client's unique situation and prescribe the correct type of financing from the entire Canadian mortgage market. We don't have just one tool; we have the entire toolbox, with access to all three tiers of lending.

Are you unsure which type of lender is right for you? Contact our brokerage today for a full strategic review of your financial situation. We will navigate the entire lending market to find the "yes" that fits you.

Get Personalized Advice

with an Award-Winning Mortgage Broker

4.9 from 812 reviews

Schedule My Call