Looking for Debt Consolidation Options in Ontario?

360Lending is an award-winning mortgage brokerage based in Richmond Hill, Ontario. Over 2,000 homeowners in Ontario have given us 5-star reviews and we have an A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau.

We help homeowners get the lowest rates for home equity loans, home equity lines of credit, refinancing, and other mortgage products.

To get approved for debt consolidation, click here to schedule a call with our team.

When you're struggling with debt, it's important to understand your options for regaining financial control. Two common solutions in Ontario are debt consolidation and consumer proposals. While both offer ways to reduce your debt burden, they differ in terms of process, eligibility, benefits, and impact on your finances. Understanding these differences can help you choose the right path to financial freedom. In this article, we’ll walk you through these two options to help you make an informed decision.

What is Debt Consolidation and How Does It Work?

Debt consolidation is a strategy that combines multiple debts into one manageable loan. The idea is simple: you take out a new loan to pay off your existing debts, leaving you with only one monthly payment to worry about.

Here’s how debt consolidation generally works:

You apply for a consolidation loan: You can work with a lender or a mortgage broker to secure a loan that will cover your debts. This can be done through a personal loan, a home equity loan, or a line of credit, depending on the amount of debt you have and your financial situation.

The loan pays off your existing debts: The funds from the consolidation loan are used to pay off your credit cards, payday loans, personal loans, and any other unsecured debts.

You make one monthly payment: Instead of juggling multiple payments to different creditors, you make a single payment to the lender who provided your consolidation loan.

The goal of debt consolidation is to make your debt more manageable, often by lowering your interest rate and extending the repayment period.

Benefits of Debt Consolidation

Simplifies your payments: With just one loan to manage, you avoid the stress of dealing with multiple creditors.

Lower interest rates: If you have high-interest debt (like credit cards), a debt consolidation loan may offer a lower interest rate.

Improved cash flow: With potentially lower monthly payments, debt consolidation can free up more cash for other expenses.

What is a Consumer Proposal?

A consumer proposal is a legally binding arrangement between you and your creditors that allows you to settle your debt for less than the full amount you owe. It’s an alternative to filing for bankruptcy and is available through a Licensed Insolvency Trustee (LIT) in Ontario.

Here’s how a consumer proposal works:

You work with a Licensed Insolvency Trustee (LIT): An LIT will help you develop a proposal that outlines how much you can realistically afford to repay to your creditors, and how long it will take.

You make a single payment: This proposal consolidates your debts into one manageable monthly payment, but unlike a consolidation loan, you don’t pay back the full amount. Instead, the proposal offers a reduced payment plan that is easier for you to manage.

Your creditors must agree: Once the proposal is presented, your creditors vote on whether to accept it. If the majority agrees, the proposal becomes binding, and you are legally protected from further collection efforts.

Unlike debt consolidation, which involves a new loan, a consumer proposal is a formal debt settlement process that doesn’t require you to borrow more money.

Benefits of a Consumer Proposal

Debt reduction: Your creditors may agree to reduce the amount you owe, often by a significant percentage.

Legal protection: Once the proposal is filed, you are protected from creditors and collection agencies. They can’t take legal action against you or continue collection efforts.

Faster path to debt relief: A consumer proposal typically lasts 3 to 5 years, providing you with a clear end date for becoming debt-free.

Eligibility Requirements for a Consumer Proposal

To qualify for a consumer proposal in Ontario, certain eligibility criteria must be met. Here’s what you need to know:

Amount of debt: You must owe at least $1,000 but no more than $250,000 (excluding your mortgage). This amount must be unsecured debt, such as credit cards, payday loans, and personal loans.

Ability to repay: You need to show that you can make regular payments toward your debts, even if the total amount is reduced. Your Licensed Insolvency Trustee will assess your income, living expenses, and other financial factors to determine a reasonable repayment plan.

Residency: You must be a resident of Ontario, and the proposal must be filed within the province.

If your debt exceeds $250,000, you may need to look into filing for bankruptcy instead.

Types of Debts to Include in a Consumer Proposal

A consumer proposal can include most unsecured debts, but there are a few exceptions. Here’s what you can and cannot include:

Included debts: Unsecured debts such as credit cards, personal loans, payday loans, and medical bills are eligible to be included in a consumer proposal.

Excluded debts: Secured debts (e.g., your mortgage or car loan) and certain government debts (e.g., child support, alimony, and some student loans) generally cannot be included in a consumer proposal.

If you have both secured and unsecured debts, a consumer proposal can still help with your unsecured debts, but you may need to handle secured debts separately.

Debt Consolidation vs. Consumer Proposal Benefits

When considering a debt consolidation loan versus a consumer proposal, it’s important to evaluate the benefits of each.

Debt Consolidation Benefits:

Simplified payments: Debt consolidation helps you organize and manage your debt with a single monthly payment.

Improved credit score potential: By paying off multiple debts, your credit score could improve over time, especially if you maintain your new payment.

Lower interest rates: If you qualify for a lower-interest consolidation loan, you can save money over time.

Consumer Proposal Benefits:

Debt reduction: With a consumer proposal, you may be able to reduce the total amount of debt you need to repay.

Legal protection: Once a proposal is filed, creditors cannot take legal action against you, and collection calls will stop.

Clear end date: A consumer proposal typically lasts 3 to 5 years, making it easier to plan for a debt-free future.

Risks of Debt Consolidation vs. Consumer Proposal

Both debt consolidation and consumer proposals come with their own set of risks, which should be carefully considered before making a decision.

Risks of Debt Consolidation:

Longer repayment period: While consolidating debt may lower your monthly payments, it can also extend the repayment period, meaning you could end up paying more interest over time.

New debt: If you’re not careful, you might accumulate more debt after consolidating, which could lead to deeper financial trouble.

Risks of a Consumer Proposal:

Impact on credit score: A consumer proposal will affect your credit score, but it’s generally less damaging than bankruptcy. However, it may make it harder to obtain new credit while you're in the proposal.

Strict repayment terms: You must stick to the repayment plan outlined in the proposal. Missing payments could lead to the proposal being canceled, leaving you with the full amount of your original debt.

Credit Impact of Debt Consolidation vs. Proposal

Your credit score plays a crucial role in your financial life, influencing everything from your ability to get a loan to the interest rates you’ll pay. When considering debt consolidation versus a consumer proposal, understanding their impact on your credit score is essential.

Debt Consolidation and Credit Score:

Improvement Potential: Debt consolidation can be a great way to improve your credit score over time. By consolidating high-interest debts like credit cards into a single loan with a lower interest rate, you can reduce the likelihood of late payments and create a more manageable monthly payment.

No Immediate Damage: Unlike a consumer proposal or bankruptcy, consolidating your debts doesn’t harm your credit score in the short term. In fact, if you stick to your repayment plan, your credit score could improve as your debt-to-income ratio improves.

Responsible Borrowing: One of the key advantages of debt consolidation is that it provides the structure for responsible borrowing. However, it’s important not to rack up more debt after consolidating, or you may undo the benefits to your credit score.

Consumer Proposal and Credit Score:

Negative Impact: A consumer proposal will have an immediate impact on your credit score. Since it’s a formal agreement with creditors to pay less than the full amount owed, it’s viewed negatively by credit reporting agencies.

Long-Term Effects: While a consumer proposal is less damaging than bankruptcy, it will still stay on your credit report for up to 3 years after you complete the proposal or 6 years from the date you file (whichever comes first). This means that for the duration of the proposal, and even for a few years afterward, you may find it difficult to obtain new credit.

While both debt consolidation and a consumer proposal will affect your credit score, debt consolidation allows for more flexibility and a faster recovery. As a mortgage brokerage, we emphasize how important it is to maintain and improve your credit score, especially if you’re planning on applying for a mortgage in the future.

Debt Consolidation Process with a Mortgage Broker

When you choose debt consolidation, a mortgage broker can be a valuable ally. Here’s what the process typically looks like:

Assessing Your Financial Situation: The first step is to sit down with a mortgage broker who will assess your financial situation, including your income, monthly expenses, and total debt. They’ll help you determine if debt consolidation is the right solution based on your unique circumstances.

Securing a Loan: Your mortgage broker will assist you in finding the best debt consolidation loan, which could be a personal loan, home equity loan, or line of credit. If you own a home and have equity, a home equity loan or line of credit may offer a lower interest rate, which is ideal for consolidating higher-interest debts like credit cards.

Planning For the Future: Once you secure the loan, the mortgage broker should help you an exit strategy and planning to help you qualify for more competitive products in the future.

The key advantage here is that you have access to a professional who can guide you through the process, secure the best loan terms, and ensure that you’re set up for financial success. By consolidating your debts, you’ll be able to focus on paying off your debt without worrying about multiple interest rates and payments.

Consumer Proposal Process with a Licensed Trustee

A consumer proposal is a more formal and complex process than debt consolidation. It involves working with a Licensed Insolvency Trustee (LIT), a professional licensed by the government to help you manage your debts.

Consultation with a LIT: To start a consumer proposal, you’ll meet with an LIT who will assess your financial situation. This includes analyzing your income, debts, and ability to make monthly payments.

Proposal Creation: The LIT will help you create a proposal that outlines how much you can afford to pay back over a 3 to 5-year period. This payment will often be less than what you owe, and you’ll make one monthly payment to the LIT, who then distributes it to your creditors.

Creditor Approval: The proposal is then submitted to your creditors, who must vote to accept it. If the majority of your creditors agree, the proposal becomes legally binding, and you’re protected from legal action and collection efforts.

While the consumer proposal process can offer significant relief, it’s not as flexible as debt consolidation. For one, you must adhere strictly to the repayment schedule, and any missed payments could cause the proposal to be revoked. Additionally, the impact on your credit score can be long-lasting, which can affect your ability to access credit in the future.

Costs of Debt Consolidation vs. Consumer Proposal

The costs and interest rates associated with each option can significantly affect your long-term financial outlook.

Debt Consolidation Costs and Interest Rates:

Interest Rates: The interest rate on a debt consolidation loan is typically much lower than the rates on credit cards or payday loans. If you have a high credit score, you may qualify for an even lower rate, which could save you money in the long term.

Loan Fees: While debt consolidation loans generally don’t have hidden fees, it’s important to be aware of any origination fees or closing costs that may be involved, depending on the type of loan you secure.

Home Equity Loans: If you own a home, you might be able to use a home equity loan or line of credit for debt consolidation. These often come with the lowest interest rates but require that you have sufficient home equity and be comfortable using your home as collateral.

Consumer Proposal Costs and Interest Rates:

When it comes to a consumer proposal, the costs are structured differently than debt consolidation. One of the key differences is that there is no interest rate tied to a consumer proposal, which can make it an attractive option for those struggling with high-interest debt.

No Interest on the Proposal: Unlike other forms of debt repayment, a consumer proposal does not accrue interest. Once the proposal is in place, your creditors cannot charge you additional interest, which can be a relief for those who are drowning in high-interest debt, such as credit cards or payday loans.

No Upfront Fees: One of the main benefits of a consumer proposal is that it doesn't require upfront fees. The Licensed Insolvency Trustee (LIT) handles the entire process and is paid through a percentage of the payments you make to your creditors. This means you won’t be hit with any surprise charges at the outset.

Payment Based on Your Income: The amount you’ll be required to pay in a consumer proposal depends on your income, the amount of debt you have, and your ability to repay. The LIT works with you to create a repayment plan that you can afford, and the proposal usually lasts between 3 to 5 years. It’s important to note that while you may be paying less than what you originally owed, the total amount you end up paying could still be significant depending on your financial situation.

Higher Payments: Although there’s no interest accruing on the debt, your total payment could still be higher than it would have been under a debt consolidation loan. This is because a consumer proposal may spread your payments over a shorter period—up to 5 years—depending on what’s agreed upon with your creditors.

What About Assets in a Consumer Proposal?

In a consumer proposal, your assets are generally protected as long as they are not part of a secured debt. However, if you own assets like a home or car, they might be at risk depending on the terms of the proposal. Unlike bankruptcy, where your assets could be liquidated to pay creditors, a consumer proposal allows you to retain ownership of your assets, making it a less disruptive option in many cases.

Impact of Consumer Proposal on Your Mortgage

A consumer proposal can complicate your mortgage renewal or refinancing options. Because a consumer proposal significantly impacts your credit score, lenders may be hesitant to offer you favorable terms when you’re ready to renew or refinance your mortgage. In some cases, you may have to wait until the consumer proposal is complete (or at least the majority of it) before qualifying for a better rate.

Payments on Your Consumer Proposal in Ontario

Missing a payment on a consumer proposal can be serious. If you fail to make a payment, your proposal could be canceled, and you’d be back to square one with your full debt obligations. This could also result in legal action from creditors, and you’d lose the protection provided by the proposal.

How to Choose The Right Debt Relief Option

Choosing between debt consolidation and a consumer proposal ultimately depends on your unique financial situation. Here are some factors to consider:

Your debt load: If your debt is overwhelming and you absolutely can’t afford to pay it back in full, a consumer proposal could offer immediate relief by reducing the amount you owe with a tradeoff for future borrowing capacity.

Your ability to repay: If you have a stable income and the ability to make consistent payments, debt consolidation may be the right choice. You’ll avoid long-term damage to your credit score and have the flexibility to pay off your debt at a manageable rate.

Credit score importance: If maintaining or improving your credit score is crucial for you—especially if you plan on applying for a mortgage soon—debt consolidation may be the better route.

Debt Consolidation vs. Consumer Proposal Ontario

While both debt consolidation and consumer proposals can help you manage your debt, debt consolidation is often the superior option—particularly if you own a home and are looking to protect your assets, avoid long-term credit score damage, and secure better mortgage rates in the future. By consolidating your debt, you’re not only simplifying your finances but also setting yourself up for a better financial future with the help of professionals like a mortgage broker.

If you’re ready to take the next step towards managing your debt effectively, reach out to us at 360Lending. We’ll work with you to find the best debt consolidation loan for your needs and help you get on the path to financial freedom.